Video: Symposium Considers AI, Ethics, and Law in Higher Ed
UniversitywideRutgers University Libraries kicked off the second year of the University Librarian’s Symposium Series on November 3 with AI in Higher Education: Ethical and Legal Considerations. About 200 people attended the hybrid symposium, which was held in person at the Archibald S. Alexander Library in New Brunswick and online via Zoom.
Watch the full event video on YouTube.
The event was the third of a four-part series on Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education, following last year’s symposia on AI in teaching and learning and AI in research. Broadly, the University Librarian’s Symposium Series aims to engage the entire Rutgers community on timely topics in higher education.
Speakers for the November 3 event represented multiple fields of study, including law, data science, health, communication, library and information science, archival studies and preservation, and computational social science.
Consuella Askew, vice president for university libraries and university librarian, welcomed the audience and discussed the Libraries’ role as an intellectual hub. “The Libraries are places of inquiry and connection, where curiosity is unleashed, knowledge is made accessible, and new ideas emerge,” she said. “It is especially appropriate that we gather here today under the Libraries' auspices.”
Johanna Bond, dean and professor of law at Rutgers Law School, spoke about the absence of regulation in the AI industry, the harms that have already resulted, and dangers for the future if nothing changes. “It may involve devastating human consequences, interference with the water supply, the power grid, or the banking system, and the law is nowhere to be found here,” she said. “Legislators in the U.S. Congress decided to adjourn in late September rather than consider kill switch legislation, which would have provided the kind of guardrails that I’m speaking about.”
Ojobo Agbo Eje, senior program coordinator for AI Campus at Rutgers–Camden, presented "Ethical AI Transformation: Designing the University We Want to Become." In his talk, he described a model for how ethical AI transformation can be accomplished at a complex institution. Part of it is understanding the motivations behind human choices, such as the choice a student might make to have AI complete an assignment—a choice that is only rewarded when a grade is based on final output rather than process. "If we truly want our students to become critical thinkers, innovators, researchers, and bold entrepreneurs, then we must create learning environments that explicitly reward unique human capacities," he said. This requires grading systems, for example, that "give more weight and value to what machines cannot do for the student," he said.
Students from the Rutgers Artificial Intelligence in Medicine and Healthcare Association spoke about "AI in Health and Medicine: Lessons for Higher Education." In their talk, they drew parallels between the issues the health care and higher education industries are facing regarding responsible AI use. Presenters included club founder Anudi Perera, Mihira Vudata, Farhana Ashiq, and Saanvika Polosa.
The final program of the symposium was a panel discussion, “Guardrails in Place?: AI Regulation (or Lack of).” The panelists were Tara Kelley, audiovisual archivist for Special Collections and University Archives at Alexander Library in New Brunswick; Katherine Ognyanova, professor of communication and director of the Rutgers Computational Social Science Lab in the School of Communication and Information at Rutgers–New Brunswick; and Britt Paris, associate professor of library and information science, also in the School of Communication and Information. They discussed the tensions between the federal government and the states on regulating AI, Silicon Valley’s strategic targeting of higher education institutions with AI products, and the problems AI misinformation presents when it comes to defining “ethical use.”
Ognyanova acknowledged that even when AI is wrong, it is incredibly persuasive—but the bigger problem is that misinformation is going largely unchallenged. She described a Rutgers Computational Social Science Lab project, State of the Prompt, which analyzed the ChatGPT conversation transcripts of about 70,000 Americans. "One of the things we looked at is how often people push back, so how often they ever say, this is not true, or I would like some more evidence about this, or is there any other source that confirms this other than you, or anything really along the lines of verification," she said. "It happens less than 1 percent of the time."
Susanna Schellenberg, distinguished professor of philosophy and cognitive science in the School of Arts and Sciences at Rutgers–New Brunswick, had to cancel her keynote presentation due to sudden and unexpected circumstances.
One final symposium on Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education, which is being planned for spring 2027, will explore AI in academic libraries. Follow the Libraries on Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, X (formerly Twitter), and Threads for details and registration to be announced.
For the Media
For questions about this story, please contact: